Disunion Feed

The Sun @BaltimoreSunMay 24, 1856 · Baltimore, Md.

Bad enough that the Senate became a theatre of venomous invective — in which, it must be conceded, Mr. Sumner is one of the adepts. But it is a humiliation, an offence to the whole country, that its sanctity should be so ruthlessly violated by the scene Mr. Brooks enacted.

Original passage & context
"It was bad enough that that hall should have been permitted to become the theatre of venomous invective and personal defamation between members, and that the tone of the public discussions there held should have been so lowered as we find them of late, (and in which, it must be conceded, Mr. Sumner appears as one of the adepts;) but it is indeed a humiliation and a degradation -- an offence, too, as it were to the whole country -- that its sanctity should have been so ruthlessly violated by such a scene as that enacted by Mr. Brooks."

Border-state moderate voice: one sentence performing the whole blame-distribution move — Sumner an 'adept' of invective in a parenthetical, Brooks's act the greater violation of the chamber's sanctity.

Next in order

Peleg W. Chandler @PelegChandler · Faneuil Hall, Boston

Every drop of blood shed in this disgraceful affair has raised up ten thousand armed men. That blood now stains the Senate floor, and not all the water of the Potomac can wash it out. They may cry, with the tragic queen, 'Out, damned spot!' — but no water can ever efface it.

Original passage & context
"Every drop of blood shed by him in this disgraceful affair has raised up ten thousand armed men. [...] that blood now stains the Senate floor; and let me tell you, that not all the water of the Potomac can wash it out. They may cry, with the great tragic queen, "Out, damned spot!" but no water of this world can ever efface it."

A self-described political opponent of Sumner ('For more than one half that period I have been his political opponent') converted by the bludgeon — the hostile-witness register that made the Faneuil Hall meeting land. Text from the authorized Works appendix; no contemporary standalone pamphlet found openly digitized. Fragments joined with [...].

Where this sits

America has argued itself to the edge before. The words come from 1854–1861; the arguments are the ones we are still having.

One passage from the caning of Charles Sumner, May 19, 1856 – Jul 14, 1856 — 19 posts, each linked to its primary source.

Part of 134 verified passages across 5 flashpoints, Jan 6, 1854 – Apr 13, 1861 — read the feed from the start.

How this was made