Disunion Feed

America has argued itself to the edge before. The words come from 1854–1861; the arguments are the ones we are still having.

New Orleans Daily Delta @NODailyDeltaMar 19, 1857 · New Orleans, La. · original ↗

For the South it is like closing the gap after the wolves have devoured the sheep — little satisfaction to know she had a right to what was stolen. "Agitation is not good for the South," say her self-appointed physicians; "she needs repose." Not when repose is death.

Next post: Charleston Mercury, Mar 27, 1857 →

Printed the same day: Albany Evening Journal →

The post above is condensed. From the original, word for word
"As far as the South is concerned, it is much like having the gap closed after the wolves have devoured all the sheep; it is but little satisfaction to her to know that she had a right to what has been stolen from her [...] "Agitation is not good for the South," says her self-appointed physicians; "she needs repose." Nay, answer we, not when repose is death."

The Delta quotes the New York Times and the Herald at length and draws the conclusion neither did: the decision hands the anti-slavery side the only solid foundation it has ever had for a national party. It also names the year the reckoning will come — 1860.

Next post: Charleston Mercury, Mar 27, 1857 →

Next in order

Between the posts

March 27. The loudest secessionist paper in the South looks again at the victory it claimed ten days ago.

Charleston Mercury @CharlestonMercury · Charleston, S.C.

They tell us, too, that we shall acquire, by the decision of the Supreme Court, not one right more than they granted us before — not one foot of slave territory more than we would have acquired without it. How much that will be, let the late history of our Government answer.

Original passage & context
"Poor deluded mortals, they tell us, too, that we shall acquire, by the decision of the Supreme Court, not one right more than they granted to us before -- not one foot of slave territory more than we would have acquired without it. How much that will be, let the late history of our Government answer."

Three weeks on, the most extreme Southern paper in the country turns on the victory it had just claimed. Its argument is that a court opinion changes nothing on the ground, and that the South is being lulled by "Union-savers" into mistaking a paper triumph for security. Written as sustained mock-scripture — the millennium has come, peace reigns, and none of it is real. The line is what the Northern papers "tell us", quoted inside that sarcasm.

Where this sits

Post 22 of 28 from the Dred Scott decision, Mar 6, 1857 – May 14, 1857 — each post linked to its primary source.

Part of 134 verified passages across 5 flashpoints, Jan 6, 1854 – Apr 13, 1861 — read the feed from the start.

How this was made