Disunion Feed

Daily Picayune @DailyPicayuneFeb 8, 1861 · New Orleans, La.

At the same moment when the Southern seceding States are uniting in convention at Montgomery to create a new government for a new Union, the border States are holding another convention at Washington City for the purpose of restoring, if possible, the old order of things.

Original passage & context
"At the same moment when the Southern seceding States are uniting in convention at Montgomery to create a new government for a new Union, the border States are holding another convention at Washington City for the purpose of restoring, if possible, the old order of things. [...] The preservation of the Union by any of the forms of the present constitution is so plainly impossible that the first and fundamental idea of any convention which looks to a further association of these thirty-four States under one government must be that the old constitution is suspended in fact as to six of the States [...] They have taken positions from which it is impossible to retreat if they desired it."

Two conventions sit in the same week: one at Montgomery building a government, one at Washington trying to save the old one. The Picayune — a conservative New Orleans daily, no fire-eater — reports the symmetry and calls the Washington effort already lost. The Peace Conference would sit until Feb 27; Congress declined to act on its proposals. Non-contiguous sentences from the one editorial joined with [...].

Next in order

Hartford Daily Courant @HartfordCourant · Hartford, Conn.

One of the bug-bears that the Secessionists have created for the purpose of frightening the timid, is that of COERCION... To “govern” means to “coerce.” It is involved in the very idea of Government... The individual rebel is the accountable being which requires the coercion.

Original passage & context
"One of the bug-bears that the Secessionists have created for the purpose of frightening the timid, is that of COERCION. It is a magic word, but unfortunately its magic applies only to the Federal Government. You cannot coerce a Sovereign State, say these State Right Abstractionists. Is that so? [...] It is worth nothing as a Government, unless there is some idea of force in its very construction. To “govern” means to “coerce.” It is involved in the very idea of Government. [...] The individual rebel is the accountable being which requires the coercion, and on whom we hope to see it exercised."

The exact answer to the Herald six days earlier (se-030), and the opposite Northern pole: coercion is not tyranny, it is what a government IS. The Courant's move is to dissolve the sovereign state into the individuals composing it — you need not coerce South Carolina, only the rebel. Capitals and small-caps as printed. Non-contiguous sentences from the one editorial joined with [...].

Where this sits

America has argued itself to the edge before. The words come from 1854–1861; the arguments are the ones we are still having.

One passage from the secession winter, Nov 9, 1860 – Apr 13, 1861 — 54 posts, each linked to its primary source.

Part of 134 verified passages across 5 flashpoints, Jan 6, 1854 – Apr 13, 1861 — read the feed from the start.

How this was made