Disunion Feed

Albany Evening Journal @AlbanyEvJournalMar 10, 1857 · Albany, N.Y.

We print to-day a sophistical, dogmatic, muddy and extreme Pro-Slavery document, which future historians will speak of as we speak of the Star Chamber. It falsifies history, belies the dead and stultifies the living — to make a local evil a National institution.

Original passage & context
"We print to-day a sophistical, dogmatic, muddy, and extreme Pro-Slavery document, which future historians will speak of as the present age speaks of the edicts of Jeffries and the Star Chamber. [...] It falsifies the most reliable history, abrogates the most solemn Law, belies the dead and stultifies the living, -- in order to make what has heretofore been a local evil, hereafter a National institution!"

Written the day the Journal printed Taney's full opinion. "Jeffries" is George Jeffreys, the Lord Chief Justice of the 1685 Bloody Assizes — in the Anglo-American press of 1857, the standard byword for a judge who serves power.

Next in order

Albany Evening Journal @AlbanyEvJournal · Albany, N.Y.

The blow annihilates the citizenship of every free colored person in the United States. Half a million men and women are disfranchised on the soil on which they were born — by the atheistic logic of the Dred Scott decision.

Original passage & context
"the barbarism of the blow which annihilates the citizenship of all the Free colored people in the United States, has fallen with a stunning force on all who have been taught that justice is obligatory on man, and that Christianity is the social law of Humanity. The half million of men and women paralysed by the atheistic logic of the decision of the case of Dred Scott, which disfranchises them on the soil on which they were born"

The part of the ruling least discussed at the time and least remembered since: the holding reached free Black Americans, not only the enslaved. The 1850 census counted about 434,000 free people of color in the United States.

Where this sits

America has argued itself to the edge before. The words come from 1854–1861; the arguments are the ones we are still having.

One passage from the Dred Scott decision, Mar 6, 1857 – May 14, 1857 — 28 posts, each linked to its primary source.

Part of 134 verified passages across 5 flashpoints, Jan 6, 1854 – Apr 13, 1861 — read the feed from the start.

How this was made