Disunion Feed

The Sun @BaltimoreSun · Baltimore, Md.

The decision just made in the Dred Scott case — an obscure African — is probably the most important that ever emanated from that highest tribunal. We cannot refrain from expressing our gratification that the subject has at last had a final adjudication.

Original passage & context
"The decision just made in the Dred Scott case, an obscure African, by the Supreme Court of the United States, is probably the most important that ever emanated from that highest tribunal of our country. [...] we cannot, in the meantime, refrain from expressing our gratification that this important subject has at last had a final adjudication"

A border-state paper in Taney's own Maryland. The phrase "an obscure African" is the Sun's, and is the period's habitual disposal of the man whose name the case carries: Dred Scott had sued for his family's freedom for eleven years.

Albany Evening Journal @AlbanyEvJournal · Albany, N.Y.

The three hundred and forty-seven thousand five hundred and twenty-five slaveholders in this Republic accomplished a great success day before yesterday — as shallow men estimate success. They converted the Supreme Court into a propagandist of human Slavery.

Original passage & context
"The three hundred and forty-seven thousand five hundred and twenty-five Slaveholders in the Republic, accomplished day before yesterday a great success -- as shallow men estimate success. They converted the Supreme Court of Law and Equity of the United States of America into a propagandist of human Slavery."

The Journal was Thurlow Weed's paper and the closest thing New York Republicans had to an official organ. Counting the slaveholders — 347,525 in the 1850 census — is the Republican argument in miniature: a minority interest capturing a national government.

Northern press · Republican Condensed — not verbatim Verified against the source — see the record
Same day, the other side: The Sun →

Where this sits

America has argued itself to the edge before. The words come from 1854–1861; the arguments are the ones we are still having.

Both of these were printed on Mar 9, 1857, inside the Dred Scott decision — 28 posts, each linked to its primary source.

Part of 134 verified passages across 5 flashpoints, Jan 6, 1854 – Apr 13, 1861 — read the feed from the start.

How this was made