Disunion Feed

Frederick Douglass @FDouglassDec 1, 1860 · Rochester, N.Y.

Lincoln's election has vitiated their authority, and broken their power. It has taught the North its strength, and shown the South its weakness. Hitherto the threat of disunion has ruled the politicians of the North; his election breaks this enchantment.

Original passage & context
"What, then, has been gained to the anti-slavery cause by the election of Mr. Lincoln? [...] Lincoln's election has vitiated their authority, and broken their power. It has taught the North its strength, and shown the South its weakness. [...] Hitherto the threat of disunion has been as potent over the politicians of the North, as the cat-o'-nine-tails is over the backs of the slaves. Mr. Lincoln's election breaks this enchantment, dispels this terrible nightmare, and awakes the nation to the consciousness of new powers."

Douglass concedes Lincoln is no abolitionist yet argues the election shattered the slaveholders' half-century grip on the Republic and broke the 'enchantment' by which disunion threats had cowed the North. Douglass' Monthly was a monthly, so no day is printed; dated to the first of the month. Verified via House Divided (Dickinson College) transcription of the December 1860 issue (primary scan at NYS Historic Newspapers). Fragments joined with [...].

Next in order

Charleston Mercury @CharlestonMercury · Charleston, S.C.

You see your enemy load his rifle with the declared purpose of taking your life — yet you are to wait, as a wise expedient of defense, until he makes the "overt act" and shoots you. Such is the 'delay' urged on the South: an absurdity only submissionists could propose.

Original passage & context
"Although you see your enemy load his rifle with the declared purpose of taking your life, you are to wait, as a wise expedient of defense, until he makes the "overt act" and shoots you. This is one of those glaring absurdities, which only such daring submissionists as BOTTS and CRITTENDEN are capable of proposing."

The Rhett family's Charleston Mercury — the organ of immediate separate-state secession — rebutting the counsels of 'delay' (wait for Virginia, wait for a Southern convention, wait for an 'overt act'). BOTTS = John Minor Botts (Va. Unionist); CRITTENDEN = John J. Crittenden (Ky., of the Crittenden Compromise), named as the 'submissionists.' Directly answers the cooperationist case of se-007. Text from the AHA "Sixteen Months to Sumter" reproduction of Dumond (transcription); excerpt is contiguous verbatim.

Where this sits

America has argued itself to the edge before. The words come from 1854–1861; the arguments are the ones we are still having.

One passage from the secession winter, Nov 9, 1860 – Apr 13, 1861 — 54 posts, each linked to its primary source.

Part of 134 verified passages across 5 flashpoints, Jan 6, 1854 – Apr 13, 1861 — read the feed from the start.

How this was made