Disunion Feed

America has argued itself to the edge before. The words come from 1854–1861; the arguments are the ones we are still having.

Valley Spirit @ValleySpiritNov 14, 1860 · Chambersburg, Pa. · original ↗

The North has rolled up a decisive majority for Abraham Lincoln. For the first time our national head is chosen by a purely sectional vote. Fifteen States are without a President. We fear the worst, yet still trust the threatened calamity may be averted.

Next post: Daily Constitutionalist, Nov 16, 1860 →

The post above is condensed. From the original, word for word
"The North has rolled up a decisive majority for ABRAHAM LINCOLN as President, and HANNIBAL HAMLIN as Vice President of the Nation. It is the first time in the history of the country that its national head has been elected by a purely sectional vote. [...] Fifteen States are without a President — they took no part in his election, and refuse their consent to come under an administration founded upon a sentiment hostile to their social system. [...] While we fear the worst results to the nation from the election of LINCOLN, we still trust that the threatened calamity may be averted, and our glorious Union still remain."

The Democratic paper in the same town as the Franklin Repository (se-002), same week — the morning-after dread: Lincoln as the first President chosen by 'a purely sectional vote,' fifteen states withholding consent. The Vice-President's name is normalized from the paper's 'HANIBAL.' Verified at Valley of the Shadow. Fragments joined with [...].

Next post: Daily Constitutionalist, Nov 16, 1860 →

Next in order

Between the posts

A week and a half after the result. In the cotton states the question is already turning from whether to how; a New York editor says let them go, and in Boston an abolitionist reads the same fury and doubts it means to act.

Daily Constitutionalist @AugustaConstitutionalist · Augusta, Ga.

The most sanguine Unionist in Georgia, if observant, must read in the signs of the times the hopelessness of the Union cause. With some southern States the question is: secession, and a self-defending southern Republic — or submission, and the fate of Jamaica and St. Domingo.

Original passage & context
"The most inveterate and sanguine Unionist in Georgia, if he is an observant man, must read, in the signs of the times, the hopelessness of the Union cause, and the feebleness of the Union sentiment in this State. [...] Some of the southern States see, in the tremendous popular majorities which have elevated LINCOLN to the Presidency, the huge mountainous waves that are beating down on the South with resistless force [...] With them the question is, secession from the Union, and a self-defending, homogeneous southern Republic, or submission to the Union, and the fate of Jamaica and St. Domingo."

A Georgia secessionist paper answering Gov. Joseph E. Brown's message; 'the fate of Jamaica and St. Domingo' invokes emancipation and slave revolt (Haiti 1791–1804; Jamaican emancipation 1834) — the core fear that remaining in the Union means the end of slavery. Text from the AHA "Sixteen Months to Sumter" reproduction of Dumond's Southern Editorials on Secession (transcription; original newspaper scan not cross-checked). Fragments joined with [...].

Where this sits

Post 3 of 54 from the secession winter, Nov 9, 1860 – Apr 13, 1861 — each post linked to its primary source.

Part of 134 verified passages across 5 flashpoints, Jan 6, 1854 – Apr 13, 1861 — read the feed from the start.

How this was made