Disunion Feed

Edgefield Advertiser @EdgefieldAdvertiserMay 28, 1856 · Edgefield, S.C.

Our Representative did exactly right, and his people will commend him highly for it. The beauty of the proceeding is that it was accomplished while the galleries had not yet emptied — while many of Sumner's constituents were there to look upon the deed. An act in good season.

Original passage & context
"For our own part, we feel that our Representative did exactly right; and we are sure his people will commend him highly for it. [...] The beauty and propriety of the proceeding consists, to no small extent, in the fact that it was accomplished while yet the galleries had not emptied themselves, and while many of Sumner's constituents were probably there to look upon the deed. [...] We have often heard of a word in good season, but this is an act in good season."

Brooks's own home-district paper — 'our Representative' is Brooks himself — celebrating not just the caning but its theatricality before Sumner's constituents. Fragments joined with [...].

Next in order

Preston S. Brooks @PrestonBrooks · Washington

With unfeigned regret I find my act construed as a breach of the privilege of the Senate. I intended only the redress of a personal wrong. I read the Senator's speech carefully. I found language unjustly reflecting upon South Carolina — and upon a friend and a relative.

Original passage & context
"It is with unfeigned regret I find in the report that what I had intended only as a redress of a personal wrong had been construed into or must necessarily be held as a breech of privilege of the Senate. [...] I had read attentively and carefully the speech delivered in the Senate on the 19th and 20th instant by the Senator from Massachusetts, and found therein language which I regarded as unjustly reflecting, not only upon the history and character of South Carolina, but also upon a friend and a relative."

Brooks in his own words, framing a near-fatal beating as mere 'redress of a personal wrong'; the Mercury's editors call the letter 'written in an admirable spirit.' Period spelling 'breech' preserved in the excerpt. Fragments joined with [...].

Where this sits

America has argued itself to the edge before. The words come from 1854–1861; the arguments are the ones we are still having.

One passage from the caning of Charles Sumner, May 19, 1856 – Jul 14, 1856 — 19 posts, each linked to its primary source.

Part of 134 verified passages across 5 flashpoints, Jan 6, 1854 – Apr 13, 1861 — read the feed from the start.

How this was made